Friday, July 20, 2007

What You Don't Read about Venezuela

I just came back from a two weeks trip to Venezuela. I had been to Margarita two years ago, but I had not been to Caracas and the interior of the country in almost 5 years.

As a fierce critic of Chavez, I have to admit that there are some major improvements that you do not read about especially in the U.S. I lived almost 20 years in Venezuela and almost 20 years in the U.S., mostly in Miami. I read and listen to almost everything that I can about Venezuela and Chavez in all the major newspapers and news programs. However, you only hear one view. You do not hear the other point of view. I agree with almost 100% everything that is written about Chavez, especially from well-respected journalists in the U.S. and Venezuela.

As I told most of my friends and relatives, in my humble point of view, there are 3 major problems with Chavez that we really need to put on top the list:

1) foreign affairs: our closest friends are Cuba and Iran, and we have horrible relations with the U.S. and also "cold" relations to put it mildly with the Europe, Mexico, Chile, and soon Brazil. My biggest concern obviously is Iran;
2) dividing the country in two groups: Chavistas and "Escualidos y Golpistas" (squalid and participant of coup d'etat). This has major consequences because of all the hatred created by Chavez, especially among families. Also, if you signed the referendum against Chavez, you cannot participate in government programs (which now is most of the economy);
3) private property: is Chavez going after everyone's private property -- just like another Cuba? Most, like me, believe it is not possible, but in Cuba, most probably thought so as well.

However, let's talk a little about what you do not read. When I arrived to Maiquetia (the main international airport near Caracas), it was completely renovated. It felt like a new modern airport in the U.S. I have been to over 80 countries, and this airport now is in the top tier. Most importantly, there is construction for new parking lots, hotels, etc. The Immigration was smooth with all the modern IT technology. I was not so pleasantly surprised to see an Iranian airline 747 parked next our American Airlines plane -- a good example of the contrast you see between the good and the bad.

The main purpose of my visit was to go to the Copa America and visit relatives and friends that I had not seen in many years. Of the two weeks, I spent 80% of the time driving throughout most of Venezuela to go to the matches. The improvements in infrastructure are impressive, including highways, bridges (the viaduct from La Guaira to Caracas can be compared to the Alps). I could not recognize the small towns that I had seen 10 years ago because of all the new highways, buildings, and so on. I was most impressed by the constructions in record time of 9 football stadiums (3 completely new and 6 redone completely). If you saw one of the games on TV, you probably thought you were watching the World Cup from Germany 2006. I have to also say that going in and out of the stadium in Maturin and Barquisimeto was a nightmare, without seat numbers, oversold, little or no security, and unfinished bathrooms and hallways, but on balance, I was very impressed. In Miami, we have been arguing for 10 years now for a new baseball stadium, and we cannot get it done despite a team that has won two World Series in 10 years.

I was also impressed with Caracas. Driving down the Francisco de Miranda and Libertador, two main avenues in Caracas, you can see a lot new and modern buildings. You have to give credit to the Mayors of Chacao, Baruta, and el Hatillo (the few left from the Opposing parties). I know personally the Mayors of Chacao and Hatillo, and it does not surprise me one bit. Chacao is a 1st World neighborhood within a 3rd World country (this was started by Irene Saez - ex-Miss Universe, who first ran against Chavez). I needed a new Cedula (national Id), which I checked on the internet for daily locations, and we asked a Chacao police officer on a motorcycle for the exact location. First, he radioed to make sure it was taking place that day, and afterwards, he told us to follow him to take us to the right place. By the way, I got my new Cedula Bolivariana relatively quickly with no need to bribe anyone (like it used to be). The Government employees were all very professional and efficient. By the way, at airport, I showed the Immigration officials my Venezuelan and U.S. passport, and I was treated very well too. I had doubts about showing my U.S passport.

I went to Cua -- a suburban town outside of Caracas -- for two days. As I was arriving to Cua, I see a modern structure that looks like space station. This is the new train station that takes you to Caracas in about 20 minutes. I did not get on the train but I had never seen a station like this in the U.S., Japan or France. Unfortunately, it was supposed to have the fastest train in the World, but because of corruption had to settle for just fast.

Finally, I was told that poor people not only get free medicines, free medical attention, preferential credits for a car, but also a free house!!! If you live in shantytown (rancho), you can apply to rebuild it or build a new one. Although, I understand only 10,000 have been built, this is an incredible program to say the least. I have to do more research on this program. My cousin quit his job in Coca Cola, and found a construction company with a partner for this program.

I also found out that Chavez forgave all the student-loans "Fundayacucho" For perspective, Fundayacucho is a Government scholarship - loans (with very low interest and provisions to forgive part or all the loan based on performance) program for Venezuelans going abroad. I was fortunate enough to benefit from Fundayacucho to pursue my MBA at Harvard Business School. Fundayacucho gave me $70,000 to pay for tuition, room & board, and based on my performance forgave $35,000. I had to pay the balance right away to stay in the U.S. Most of my friends and family, who went to Ivy League Schools, with Fundayacucho stayed in the U.S. I remembered that none of my friends from other countries at Harvard had such program.

My family and friends from the Opposition say: "yes, it all true, but the bad outweighs the good". I agree with them, but nobody talks about the good. Most of the Venezuelan population is affected directly by the "good" and not so much by the "bad". I also want to mention that I did not feel in any moment that I could say what I wanted when I wanted even among Chavistas. I saw an interview in Globovision of a ex-Secretary of Defense. I could not believe the questions and accusations that the interviewer was making about corruption and Chavez. Even if they are all true, the point is that the lack of freedom of speech is exaggerated to say the least. I watch all the O'Reilly, Hannity & Colmes, Matthews, and all the Sunday shows, and I never have seen an interviewer accused a Government official in such a way.

I have always voted against Chavez and I still consider myself radically opposed to Chavez policies and his behavior, but I cannot ignore some of the good that has been done with the Petrodollars, and may be some journalists in the U.S. should do the same.

I truly enjoyed my trip to Venezuela, and I cannot wait to come back again. Although I recognized that this is only a small non-representative sample of experiences, I wanted to mention what you don't read about especially in U.S. papers.

6 comments:

Unknown said...

i think this is like you say "just a point of view and i truly believe that is affected by the fact that you have lived into a different organization of country" better or not... doesn't matter right now, but all too near to the reality. Congratulations for saying something after havin' a clear perpective of the real version!

Juan Carrero.

leftside said...

I will be linking to this post on my humble blog. It was very informative and interesting, especially coming from someone who is a "fierce critic of Chavez." Your honesty is much appreciate.

memememe said...

Right, Chavez is building a lot of stuff... but you dont live under him... you dont experience the shortages at the supermarkets, you dont feel the menaces against your university, you dont have some friends in jail or shooted ... I dont care how many modern buildings hes making, if we are losing our freedom in return. It is sad that people here are commenting about this "real perspective", for them populism messures is the best way to know if a government is making a good job or not.

Anonymous said...

Lei tu articulo y no entiendo muy bien lo que quieres lograr con el mismo. Creo que si vas a hacer un nalisis de la situacion en Venezuela deberias profundizar un poco mas el tema y llegar a conclusiones un poco mas claras y especificas.
Yo tambien estuve en Venezuela y aunque estuve solo en Caracas y por muy poco tiempo, y estoy de acuerdo contigo que el aeropuerto esta mucho mejor, yo diria que la situacion en general es precaria, y el futuro que se vislumbra es todavia peor.
En mi opinion si es importante enfatizar los negativos los cuales superan con creces a cualquier cosa positiva que pueda estar pasando. Aademas si la cosa sigue asi el pais se va a la mierda.
No creo que es el momento de hablar de estadios y aeropuertos como un reflejo positivo del gobierno de Chavez. Y si hay que hablar de la falta de libertad, la corrupcion que esta peor que antes, las intimidaciones del gobierno, una empresa privada en total decadencia, una clase media casi desaperecida, una inseguridad grandisima, una division del pais tajante entre Chavistas y los otros, la fuga de gente preparada , desconfianza en el futuro, etc, etc, etc.
Pedistes que opinaramos, y por eso te doy la mia.

Carlos Erban said...

I have received many comments from friends and family on both side of the issue. I appreciate all of your comments because I think that we need to have a productive debate, which unfortunately, we do not have now, because the "radicals" on both side have taken over the debate.

Let me clarify that I am not in support for Chavez. Quite the contrary, I have voted against him in every single electoral process and signed the "firmazo". I am proud of it, and would do it again. I also think that he cheated in the referendum and the elections were undemocratic because they were done under threat by the Government. Nobody knows who would have won if everybody would have voted for whom they wanted under no threat of retribution. The point of my article is to bring up some of the reasons whey Chavez still has a lot support, especially from the poor. Here in Miami, the media coverage is very poor. The programs invite only radicals who talk about how to get rid of Chavez and constantly describe how Venezuela is already another Cuba. Here people basically watch Baily (who has become now a comedian and calls Chavez a killer everyday) and Polos Opuestos, who invites Patricia Poleo and Orlando Urdaneta to provide only their POV with some Cuban exile leader who has not been or has no idea what's happening in Venezuela and says that everything is like Cuba. The articles and columns in the Herald, WSJ, NYT are superficial at best and talk about the obvious. I know some of the young Opposition leaders, who are not radical, and should be given a chance to explain the situation, especially in Miami. This a complicated and deep issue with no debate, and that's the reason why I bring up some of the reasons why Chavez has support to start a productive debate. Hopefully, the University students set the example and start a real debate. Keep up the comments.

Anonymous said...

Recibe mis felicitaciones por el excelente artículo que nos has brindado. Para muchos es difícil "desnudarse" de prejuicios y emitir una opinión equilibrada sobre la situación en Venezuela. Basta darse un paseo por la historia de nuestro país para entender que desde la llegada de Colón a estas tierras, hemos estado divididos en dos bandos:patriotas y realistas, centralistas y federalistas, pro-dictatoriales y anti-dictatoriales, adecos y copeyanos, oficialistas y opositores. Buenos o malos, todos pasan y seguirán pasando; si cada venezolano se compromete a cumplir su parte, eventualmente llegaremos a ser ciudadanos y no simples habitantes.

Alicia Rodríguez